
Given his determination to swing a socialist wrecking ball at our national economy, it’s no surprise that Bernie Sanders also embraces destructive policies at the local level. He’s a NIMBY (for “Not In My Back Yard”), recently declaring his opposition to constructing 10,000 badly-needed housing units on a defunct race track in East Boston, tweeting that “we need affordable housing for all instead of more gentrifying luxury developments for the few.”
Of course, claiming to serve the interests of the poor while protecting one’s own is a commonplace. Locally, in D.C.’s Ward 3 – its wealthiest – residents have delayed or stopped a proposed apartment building and organic market. In investment-starved Baltimore City, the well-heeled residents of Roland Park recently won a lengthy court battle preventing construction of 148 new apartments.
I’ve seen how this works out in the long run, and it’s not pretty. In California, my mother-in-law was a dedicated NIMBY. She often complained that, thanks to rising home prices, her kids might not be able to afford to live in the Golden State. But if anyone proposed building anything – especially higher-density housing – in her sprawling suburb, she would join her neighbors in protests against it.
This led to interesting discussions with her insensitive son-in-law, who would say things like “can’t have it both ways, mom. It’s supply and demand: you limit supply, and your kids pay through the nose on their rent or mortgage – or they just move away.” Which provoked lengthy rebuttals, during which “loss of green space,” “traffic congestion,” and “preserving quality of life” got prominent mention.
Ultimately, California’s NIMBYs won that debate. Since 1990, the state has allowed construction of only one-third as many homes (on a per-capita basis) as it did in the previous three decades. It now ranks last in the U.S. in homes-per-household, which therefore have a median price (over $550k) that is more than twice the national average and second-highest in the country (behind only Hawaii). These days, half of my mother-in-law’s offspring live elsewhere and only one of seven grandchildren remains in California; he lives with two apartment-mates and has a hellish 1.5-hour-each-way commute between his job and affordable housing.

